Govt. Claims/Sovereign Immunity

Government to Seek Supreme Court Review of Purdue’s Third-Party, Nondebtor Releases

In a motion to stay the issuance of the mandate, the government has announced that it will be filing a petition for certiorari asking the Supreme Court to review the Second Circuit’s Purdue decision allowing bankruptcy courts to issue releases to nondebtors. The Second Circuit’s May 30 decision reversed the district court and reinstated the bankruptcy court’s confirmation of the chapter 11 plan of Purdue Pharma LP. The New York-based court of appeals held that chapter 11 plans may include nonconsensual releases of creditors’ direct claims against nondebtors. Purdue Pharma LP v. City of Grand Prairie (In re Purdue Pharma LP), 69 F.4th (2d Cir. May 30, 2023). The motion filed by the government on July 7 states that “the [U.S.] Solicitor General has determined to seek review of the panel’s decision in the Supreme Court” before the August 28 deadline. The government’s motion characterized Purdue’s chapter 11 plan as giving absolute, unconditional and permanent releases “from every conceivable type of opioid-related civil” claims to members of the Sackler family that owned and controlled the company.

Please note that in order to view the content for the Bankruptcy Headlines you must either sign in if you are already an ABI member, or otherwise you may Become an ABI Member

Government to Seek Supreme Court Review of Purdue’s Third-Party, Nondebtor Releases

In a motion to stay the issuance of the mandate, the government has announced that it will be filing a petition for certiorari asking the Supreme Court to review the Second Circuit’s Purdue decision allowing bankruptcy courts to issue releases to nondebtors.

IRS Has No Sovereign Immunity to Bar a Fraudulent Transfer Suit Under Section 544(b)

The circuits are now split 3/1, with the majority finding a waiver of sovereign immunity under Section 544(b)(1) for lawsuits by a trustee based on claims that an actual creditor could not have brought outside of bankruptcy.
Court: 

Supreme Court: The Bankruptcy Code Waived Tribes’ Sovereign Immunity

The Supreme Court resolved a split of circuits in an opinion that could give support to the notion that arbitration agreements are not enforceable in bankruptcy.

Second Circuit Reverses, Reinstates Purdue’s Nondebtor, Third-Party Releases

The concurring opinion, which is really a dissent, urges the Supreme Court to grant certiorari and resolve the split of circuits on nondebtor releases.
Court: 

Supreme Court Holds that Real Estate Tax Foreclosures Can Violate the Takings Clause

The high court’s ruling on the Takings Clause also seems to mean that real estate tax foreclosures can be avoided as constructively fraudulent transfers.

Pages